QUOTE(dave mcbride @ Jan 14 2006, 12:32 AM)
no offense, but the american military has been wrong more often than not all along about this stuff (read "assassins gate" by george packer for evidence on this). zawahiri was a struggling jihadist for 15 years after the assassination of sadat, but islamic jihad never achieved anything more than regional marginality. in 95-96, he had the brilliant idea (and he is indeed quite smart) to hitch himself to bin laden's star. bin laden is a world historical figure, on the order of lenin, khomeini, ho chi minh, and havel. zawahiri is a beria, a hess, a zhou en lai-- the guy that everyone claims is smarter but has no capacity to inspire the masses. bin laden, regardless of his reprehensible ideology, has that capability.
[right][snapback]566470[/snapback][/right]
No doubt Bin Laden is a charismatic figure to fundamentalists but Zawahiri is still a huge blow to al quaeda. I havent read Assassins Gate but I have read Bodansky, Bergen and Janes.
http://www.janes.com/security/internationa...11003_1_n.shtmlQUOTE
While Bin Laden has the charisma and the funds that built the Al-Qaeda (The Base) network of Islamic fundamentalists, mainly from the men who followed him during the fighting against the Soviets in Afghanistan in the 1980s, al-Zawahiri is widely seen by counterterrorism and Islamic specialists as the intellect and ideological driving force behind the organisation.
QUOTE
According to Vincent Cannistraro, former top CIA counterterrorist official, "Zawahiri is the guy-he's the operational commander...number one, on the right hand side of Osama."